Should I get the Sidekick 4g or Motorola Cliq 2?

I want either of these two phones because of the keyboard. I like the sidekick because of the 4g and color. But I dislike the size and the name Sidekick. I like the Cliq because it's smaller and looks more modern and the camera. But I dislike that it's 3g and the keyboard is kinda ugly. So is the 3g and 4g much difference? Which phone is better? Thanks(: